/s/ Ryoichi Yonemura
|
(Signature)
|
Ryoichi Yonemura
|
General Manager
|
Strategic Planning Department
|
(Name and Title)
|
November 8, 2010
|
(Date)
|
1. Date and Time:
|
November 5, 2010 (Friday), at 10 a.m.
|
|
2. Place:
|
New Pier Hall, 1st floor, New Pier Takeshiba North Tower 11-1, Kaigan
1-chome, Minato-ku, Tokyo
|
3. Shareholders Entitled to Exercise Their Voting Rights
|
||
Total number of shareholders entitled to exercise their voting rights:
|
12,357 persons
|
|
Voting rights held by all shareholders entitled to exercise their voting rights:
|
131,847 units
|
|
4. Shareholders Who Attended the Meeting
|
||
Number of shareholders present entitled to exercise their voting rights:
|
238 persons
|
|
Number of voting rights held by the shareholders present entitled to exercise their voting rights:
|
68,336 units
|
|
Number of shareholders entitled to exercise their voting rights, who submitted the Voting Rights Exercise Form:
|
2,805 persons
|
|
Number of voting rights held by the shareholders entitled to exercise their voting rights, who submitted the Voting Rights Exercise Form:
|
26,074 units
|
|
Number of shareholders who exercised their voting rights (in total):
|
3,043 persons
|
|
Number of voting rights held by the shareholders who exercised their voting rights (in total):
|
94,410 units
|
Shareholder A:
|
1)
|
Why did such a scandal happen at Mercian Corporation (“Mercian”), which is a listed company that has had good compliance and in which the statutory auditors execute their duties well?
|
2)
|
How do you intend to develop Mercian’s strengths in the future?
|
|
Chairman:
|
1)
|
Even our accounting audits and internal audits failed to catch the skillfully deceptive fraudulent transactions, which included transfers of inventories between warehouses, the use of dummy products for feedstuff inventories, false certificates of deposit balance and collaboration with outsiders on the deceptions.
|
In the future, we intend to address tasks such as a review of business processes, focusing on compliance, personnel rotation, enhancing the audit function and thorough financial inspections not only on the feedstuffs business but also on companywide business activities.
|
||
2)
|
We intend to develop our strengths through enhanced collaboration with the Group companies of Kirin Holdings Company, Limited (“KH”) by growing the Mercian brand for the core business centering on wines.
|
|
Shareholder B:
|
1)
|
I understand that the “reinforcement of the management base” is one major reason to become a wholly owned subsidiary of KH. However, what do you mean when you say that the purpose is to reinforce corporate governance by becoming a wholly owned subsidiary? Do you mean that Mercian cannot reinforce corporate governance with ordinary shareholders like us?
|
2)
|
I wonder if the genuine officers of Mercian might have had difficulty expressing their opposing viewpoint on becoming a wholly owned subsidiary of KH because of the scandal.
|
|
Chairman:
|
1)
|
Taking into account the ineffective supervision of the Fish Feedstuffs Division’s businesses, corporate governance should be reinforced by becoming a wholly owned subsidiary, in management’s opinion, through enhanced collaboration with KH and swifter decision making.
|
2)
|
I, Hiroshi Ueki, and Koichi Matsuzawa, President of Kirin Brewery Company, Limited (“KB”), did not participate in voting on the relevant
|
resolutions. The matter was discussed with reference to legal advisers’ opinion and opposite opinions were also discussed.
|
Shareholder C:
|
I will become a shareholder of KH’s less-than-one-unit shares. Is it possible for Mercian to dispense with the purchase commission for the relevant shareholders if they request that KH sell the number of shares that will constitute one unit share in total? In addition, do you intend to show goodwill toward your shareholders by sending several wine bottles as a token of your apology?
|
Chairman:
|
The share exchange rate was calculated by independent third party valuation institutions that were requested by KH and Mercian. The delivery of less-than-one-unit shares was not initially determined by the share exchange. I am extremely sorry to have been unable to prevent the scandal. Management will strive to rebuild shareholders’ trust by making efforts to prevent the recurrence of similar incidents.
|
Shareholder D:
|
But why did it take so long to reveal such a serious issue?
|
Chairman:
|
We failed to identify the fraudulent acts because the deceptions were so skillful. Again, we reflect on the weakness of our internal control. First and foremost, we want to improve our internal control.
|
Shareholder E:
|
Didn’t you vote for the resolution by giving extra consideration to KH as you came from KB?
|
You have not yet provided a detailed explanation on the scandal. Didn’t you make a claim for damages against the officers who were involved in the scandal? I would like to ask the statutory auditor to address this question.
|
|
Chairman:
|
To avoid conflicts of interest, I didn’t participate in the resolutions regarding the share exchange. They were adopted from a neutral standpoint.
|
Statutory Auditor Koki Kiyoshima:
|
|
As active involvement in the scandal by any specific officer has not been ascertained according to the report by the Third Party Committee, we have no intention of making a claim for damages at this time.
|
|
Shareholder F:
|
Although you insist no officer was actively involved, isn’t it possible that an officer may have been peripherally responsible? Shouldn’t you retroactively investigate and evaluate the past behavior of the management executives? What will the employee morale be like given the current situation?
|
Chairman:
|
Although we recognized superficial phenomena such as considerable delays in
|
crediting trade accounts receivable and the buildup of inventories, we could not determine inappropriate trade and misconduct. We reprimanded several officers on August 20, 2010. In addition, several former executive managing directors and corporate senior vice presidents returned part of their retirement benefits and/or remuneration.
|
|
Shareholder G:
|
I think that the inappropriate trade had already started during the tenure of President Suzuki. Why couldn’t his successor reveal the irregularities? Also, does Mercian intend to integrate or abolish a plant given that KB is abolishing two of its plants?
|
Chairman:
|
The inappropriate trade started in 2004 during the tenure of his immediate successor and not during the tenure of the former President Suzuki. We again apologize that we could not find the irregularities. As for the second question, we do not have a plan to integrate or abolish a plant at this time.
|
Shareholder H:
|
What was the cause of the inappropriate trade, in your opinion?
|
Chairman:
|
I can mention the following four causes or motivations of the inappropriate trade: The fictitious recording of trade accounts receivable by fish farmers; the recording of fictitious sales to compensate for fictitious inventories; circular transactions to conceal massive bad inventories; and the recording of fictitious sales in the pursuit of the continuation of the Feedstuffs Division.
|
Shareholder I:
|
Will the Mercian Karuizawa Museum of Art survive after Mercian becomes a wholly owned subsidiary of KH? How will Mercian’s hospitality programs for shareholders be handled (e.g., the distribution of museum tickets and wines)? Will you continue to provide such privileges to Mercian’s former shareholders?
|
Chairman:
|
We intend to continue operating the Museum at this time. The continuation of the current hospitality programs for shareholders will be determined by KH’s management, therefore the management of Mercian cannot answer this question. Anyway, we will forward your request.
|
Shareholder J:
|
I read an article in today’s Nikkei Shimbun that said Mercian will suspend its fish feedstuffs business. How do you plan to deal with the fish feedstuffs business in the future?
|
Chairman:
|
Currently, we are studying various possibilities including the continuation, assignment and liquidation of the business as options. Selling the business is not our top priority. We will reach a final decision on its treatment by the end of 2010.
|
Shareholder K:
|
I’ve heard that you as President and CEO and Mr. Matsuzawa will remain as directors of KH. Who on Mercian’s management team will stay on as management executives in KH? I’m afraid that Mercian’s originality could disappear unless several genuine officers remain as directors. What about this point?
|
Chairman:
|
I will remain an Outside Director of KH, whereas Mr. Matsuzawa will be the President and CEO of KB. No other transfer of Mercian officers is scheduled at this time.
|
Shareholder L:
|
I am an admirer of Mercian shares and a devotee of Mercian wines. I feel that Mercian is now being engulfed by a large company in Kirin. I find it difficult to approve this proposition because Kirin’s attitude as to the treatment of Mercian is unclear.
|
Chairman:
|
To our regret, I think the scandal has greatly discredited Mercian. Management therefore determined that becoming a wholly owned subsidiary of KH would be most desirable to regain people’s confidence as soon as possible. We are not in a position to comment on Kirin’s attitude. We hope that Mercian shareholders will become shareholders of KH, which includes Mercian as a Group company.
|
7. Chairman of the Meeting:
|
Hiroshi Ueki, President and CEO
|
8. Director Who Prepared These Minutes:
|
Hiroshi Ueki, President and CEO
|